Friday, September 18, 2009

Might Be Time for Varitek to Retire

Dad --

I know my title is a bold statement to make, especially since I, like most of Red Sox Nation, really wanted him back this year. And for the first half of the season I felt justified in my desires. He was hitting and covering the bag like he used to. Unfortunately since the All Star Break the Captain just hasn't been performing. His batting average is down and since we acquired Martinez he hasn't been spending nearly as much time behind the plate.

But last night he was back. Mainly because Beckett doesn't like pitching to anyone else. And last night Beckett paid for it.

After giving up a solo shot to Kendrick in the top of the 3rd the Sox were able to get the lead back in the bottom of the fourth with three runs. Everything looked fine until the 7th. Beckett got two quick outs but then fell apart.

Kendrick singled to left. Then Izturis pinch hit a ground-rule double to right. I and Red Sox Nation exhaled because that ground rule double saved a run. At least it should have. But while facing the next batter, Beckett threw a low pitch that Varitek couldn't handle. The ball went right between his legs and skidded to the back stop allowing Kendrick to score from third and tie up the game.

Now I know what you're going to say. There were still three chances for the Sox to regain the lead. And yes, it was Billy Wagner who gave up the game winning run in the 9th. But it was Varitek's mistake that gave the Angels the momentum they'd been looking for all series.

It was a sad moment. Not because we lost, but because it shined a light on what Theo Epstein and the rest of Red Sox management may have known since last year - Varitek just isn't the catcher he used to be. And maybe now, at the age of 36, he should really consider making this season his last.

Don't get me wrong, I love Varitek. He's been a great asset to the team and he's absolutely one of the best catchers in the majors, but unfortunately baseball is a young man's game and he's just not the spry guy he used to be. Besides, it's not like we don't have anywhere to turn. Victor Martinez has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt, he can easily take over for the Captain. And he has, on more than one occasion.

Dad, I hate to admit it, but last night made it imminently clear - it's time for Varitek to pass down his mask.

Jenn

1 comment:

Jenn and Peter said...

Well, Jenn, I'v ethought long and hard about it as well. He's definitely having his problems, but who, at 36, is as quick as they are at 26? For now, at least, I'll rely on the 'wisdom' of another catcher, HoF'er (and a Yank, damn it), who said, "It ain't over til it's over." Yogi did ghave a point, but I AM thinking about the possibility. Having Martinez makes the blow somewhat easier, but still....
Dad